Point of Order
May 11, 2023
Point of order concerning the requirement for a royal recommendation for Bill C-319, An Act to amend the Old Age Security Act (amount of full pension)
Hon. Anthony Rota
Speaker of the House
Ruling Text
The Deputy Speaker:
The Chair is now prepared to rule on the point of order raised by the deputy House leader of the government on April 19, 2023, regarding Bill C-319, an act to amend the Old Age Security Act (amount of full pension), standing in the name of the member for Shefford.
In a statement concerning Private Members' Business on March 30, 2023, the Chair invited members to make arguments regarding the need for this bill to be accompanied by a royal recommendation.
[English]
In her statement, the deputy House leader of the government noted that Bill C-319 would increase the amount of the full pension for Canadians aged 65 to 74 by 10%. This increase is not provided for by the Old Age Security Act. She argued that, as a result, this charge against the consolidated revenue fund is not authorized by the act or any other.
[Translation]
The increase in the amount of the full pension that Bill C-319 would provide to all pensioners aged 65 or older would raise public spending for purposes not currently authorized by the Act. Consequently, the Chair is of the opinion that the bill infringes on the financial prerogative of the Crown and needs a new royal recommendation if it is to receive a final vote in the House at third reading.
The House will soon take up the second reading motion for the bill, which can be put to a vote at the conclusion of debate on that motion.
I thank all members for their attention.
Edit Metadata
Holding
"Bill C-319 requires a royal recommendation to proceed to a third reading vote because it proposes a new charge against the consolidated revenue fund not currently authorized by statute."
AI Summary
The Chair ruled that Private Member's Bill C-319 requires a royal recommendation because it increases spending not currently authorized by the Old Age Security Act.
AI Analysis
- Outcome
- Sustained
- Tone
- Educational
- Procedural Stage
- Private Members' Business
- Significance
Low
High