Skip to content
Point of Order May 13, 2022

Point of order concerning the form of Bill C-19, Budget Implementation Act, 2022, No. 1

Hon. Anthony Rota

Hon. Anthony Rota

Speaker of the House

Ruling Text

The Deputy Speaker: Following the point of order raised by the member for Joliette, I would like to provide clarification concerning Bill C-19, an act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on April 7, 2022 and other measures. The member noted that the paper copy of the bill obtained in the lobby differed from the version found on the parliamentary web site. It would seem that there are some pages missing. Consequently, he asked which version is the correct one. He asked the Chair for clarification concerning the rules. The Office of the Law Clerk and Parliamentary Counsel was consulted, and I would like to assure members that the first reading copy that was signed by the minister and the Clerk contains all the clauses of the bill. The problem seems to be with the reproduction of the advance copies available in the lobbies. The Speaker notes that these copies are provided by the government so that members can read the key provisions of the bill. After first reading, the bill is published officially, which might change the pagination and line numbers of the version used for the purposes of the House of Commons. The copy placed in the lobby is therefore not the official version published under the authority of the Speaker. The version available on the LEGIS info website is verified by the Office of the Law Clerk and Parliamentary Counsel before it is put online.
Edit Metadata

AI Summary

The Speaker ruled that the official version of a bill is the one published online, not the potentially incomplete advance paper copies available in the lobby.

AI Analysis

Holding
"The official version of a bill is the one verified by the Office of the Law Clerk and Parliamentary Counsel and published on the LEGISinfo website, not the advance paper copies provided in the lobby."
Outcome
Denied
Tone
Educational
Procedural Stage
Speaker's Ruling
Significance
Low High

Cited Authorities

Tags & Keywords