Recorded divisions: casting vote

Skip to main content Parliament of Canada Visit Parliament Visit Français FR Share Email Facebook LinkedIn Twitter Menu Parliamentary Business Parliamentary Business - Home The House Sitting Calendar House Publications Bills (LEGIS info ) Written Questions Petitions Votes Search the Debates (Hansard) Status of House Business Committees List of Committees and Overview Meetings Bills in Committee (LEGIS info ) Studies, Activities and Reports Search the Transcripts Participate Resources Procedural Information Library of Parliament Legislative Summaries Research Publications Parliamentary Historical Resources (1867-1993) Parliamentary Diplomacy Parliamentary Diplomacy - Home Speakers' Activities Parliamentary Associations Visits and Events Conferences Parliamentary Officers' Study Program Members Members - Home Members and Roles Members of Parliament The Speaker Ministry (Cabinet) Parliamentary Secretaries Party Leaders and other House Officers Related Information Party Standings Seating Plan Members' Expenditures Registry of Designated Travellers A Member's Typical Week Resources Contact Members of Parliament Constituencies Library of Parliament Historical Information (PARLINFO) Participate Participate - Home The House Attend Live Debates Watch and Listen to Chamber Proceedings Create or Sign a Petition A Typical Week at the House Contact a Member of Parliament Follow a Bill (LEGIS info ) Committees Attend Meetings Watch and Listen to Committee Proceedings Current Consultations How to Submit a Brief and Appear Layout of a Typical Committee Room Contact a Committee Resources Procedural Information Library of Parliament Classroom Activities Teacher Resources Teachers Institute About the House About the House - Home Transparency and accountability Board of Internal Economy By-Laws and Policies Members' Allowances and Services House Administration Reports and Disclosure Conflict of Interest Code for Members Accessibility Arts and Heritage History, Art and Architecture Future of the Parliamentary Precinct Memorial Chamber Carillon In pictures Virtual Tour of the House Live Hill Cam Photo Gallery Employment Employment - Home Working for the administration Current Opportunities at the House of Commons Eligibility and Selection General Application Who We Are and What We Offer Student Opportunities Student Employment Page Program Parliamentary Internship Programme Working for a Member of Parliament Current Listed Opportunities Working for a Member of Parliament Search Search Search Search Source Full website Member Bill Topic Petition Writen Question Parliamentary Business Parliamentary Business - Home The House Sitting Calendar House Publications Bills (LEGIS info ) Written Questions Petitions Votes Search the Debates (Hansard) Status of House Business Committees List of Committees and Overview Meetings Bills in Committee (LEGIS info ) Studies, Activities and Reports Search the Transcripts Participate Resources Procedural Information Library of Parliament Legislative Summaries Research Publications Parliamentary Historical Resources (1867-1993) Parliamentary Diplomacy Parliamentary Diplomacy - Home Speakers' Activities Parliamentary Associations Visits and Events Conferences Parliamentary Officers' Study Program Members Members - Home Members and Roles Members of Parliament The Speaker Ministry (Cabinet) Parliamentary Secretaries Party Leaders and other House Officers Related Information Party Standings Seating Plan Members' Expenditures Registry of Designated Travellers A Member's Typical Week Resources Contact Members of Parliament Constituencies Library of Parliament Historical Information (PARLINFO) Participate Participate - Home The House Attend Live Debates Watch and Listen to Chamber Proceedings Create or Sign a Petition A Typical Week at the House Contact a Member of Parliament Follow a Bill (LEGIS info ) Committees Attend Meetings Watch and Listen to Committee Proceedings Current Consultations How to Submit a Brief and Appear Layout of a Typical Committee Room Contact a Committee Resources Procedural Information Library of Parliament Classroom Activities Teacher Resources Teachers Institute About the House About the House - Home Transparency and accountability Board of Internal Economy By-Laws and Policies Members' Allowances and Services House Administration Reports and Disclosure Conflict of Interest Code for Members Accessibility Arts and Heritage History, Art and Architecture Future of the Parliamentary Precinct Memorial Chamber Carillon In pictures Virtual Tour of the House Live Hill Cam Photo Gallery Employment Employment - Home Working for the administration Current Opportunities at the House of Commons Eligibility and Selection General Application Who We Are and What We Offer Student Opportunities Student Employment Page Program Parliamentary Internship Programme Working for a Member of Parliament Current Listed Opportunities Working for a Member of Parliament Search Search Search Search Source Full website Member Bill Topic Petition Writen Question Search all ProceduralInfo Overview Procedure and Practice Standing Orders Speakers' Decisions Our Procedure Glossary Selected Decisions of Speaker Peter Milliken 2001 - 2011 Selected Decisions Peter Milliken The Decision-making Process Miscellaneous Table of Contents Previous Next The Decision-making Process / Miscellaneous Recorded divisions: casting vote March 4, 2010 Debates, p. 21 Context On December 10, 2009, the deferred recorded division on the motion for the third reading of Bill C-291, An Act to amend the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (coming into force of sections 110, 111 and 171) , resulted in an equality of voices (143 votes in favour and 143 votes against), so the Speaker gave the casting vote. In keeping with the conventions governing the casting vote, he voted to maintain the status quo , which in this case meant voting against the motion, and thus the motion was defeated. [1] On March 4, 2010, the Speaker delivered a statement with regard to the result of this vote. He noted that it had been brought to the attention of the Table that an error had occurred in that Joseph Volpe (Eglinton–Lawrence) had been counted as having voted in favour of the motion when in fact he had not voted at all. The Speaker pointed out that the outcome of the vote remained the same: the motion for third reading of Bill C-291 remained defeated, but this time on a vote of 142 yeas to 143 nays. He informed the House that, in keeping with the precedents applicable to the discovery of such errors, a corrigendum was published on December 30, 2009 to correct the Journals of December 10, 2009, [2] to reflect the true result of the vote. Statement of the Chair The Speaker: Before we proceed with Routine Proceedings, I have an important statement I would like to make to the House about the result of a vote taken on December 10, 2009, on the motion for third reading of Bill C-291, An Act to amend the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (coming into force of sections 110, 111 and 171) . As hon. Members will recall, the announced result was a tie, with 143 Members recorded as having voted in favour and 143 Members recorded as having voted against. On hearing that the votes were equally divided on the motion, I gave the casting vote in the negative on the procedural grounds that the existing Act should be maintained in its current form in order to uphold the status quo . Since then, it was brought to the attention of the Table that a Member had been erroneously counted as having voted yea. Further verifications were made to confirm that an error had in fact been made, namely that the hon. Member for Eglinton–Lawrence had remained seated throughout the vote. As hon. Members will realize, if this yea vote had not been counted in error, events would have unfolded differently. No tie vote would have occurred. No casting vote would have been required. However, and most significantly, the outcome of the vote remains the same. The motion for third reading of Bill C-219 remains defeated, but on a vote of 142 yeas and 143 nays. Accordingly, in keeping with precedents for when such errors are discovered, I am informing the House that a corrigendum was published on December 30 to correct the Journals of December 10, 2009, so that the true result of the vote may be properly reflected in our official records. I thank hon. Members for their attention to this detail. It is an important one from the point of view of the number of casting votes the Chair has to cast in the House. Some third-party websites may not be compatible with assistive technologies. Should you require assistance with the accessibility of documents found therein, please contact accessible@parl.gc.ca . [1] Debates, December 10, 2009, pp. 7936-7 . [2] Journals, December 10, 2009, pp. 1200-2 . For questions about parliamentary procedure, contact the Table Research Branch 613-996-3611 trbdrb@parl.gc.ca Top of page Senate Library of Parliament Parliamentary Protective Service Employment at Parliament Follow Us Important Notices Open Data Info for Media Site Map Accessibility Contact Us