Establishment of first Order of Precedence: Speaker's statement regarding royal recommendation

Skip to main content Parliament of Canada Visit Parliament Visit Français FR Share Email Facebook LinkedIn Twitter Menu Parliamentary Business Parliamentary Business - Home The House Sitting Calendar House Publications Bills (LEGIS info ) Written Questions Petitions Votes Search the Debates (Hansard) Status of House Business Committees List of Committees and Overview Meetings Bills in Committee (LEGIS info ) Studies, Activities and Reports Search the Transcripts Participate Resources Procedural Information Library of Parliament Legislative Summaries Research Publications Parliamentary Historical Resources (1867-1993) Parliamentary Diplomacy Parliamentary Diplomacy - Home Speakers' Activities Parliamentary Associations Visits and Events Conferences Parliamentary Officers' Study Program Members Members - Home Members and Roles Members of Parliament The Speaker Ministry (Cabinet) Parliamentary Secretaries Party Leaders and other House Officers Related Information Party Standings Seating Plan Members' Expenditures Registry of Designated Travellers A Member's Typical Week Resources Contact Members of Parliament Constituencies Library of Parliament Historical Information (PARLINFO) Participate Participate - Home The House Attend Live Debates Watch and Listen to Chamber Proceedings Create or Sign a Petition A Typical Week at the House Contact a Member of Parliament Follow a Bill (LEGIS info ) Committees Attend Meetings Watch and Listen to Committee Proceedings Current Consultations How to Submit a Brief and Appear Layout of a Typical Committee Room Contact a Committee Resources Procedural Information Library of Parliament Classroom Activities Teacher Resources Teachers Institute About the House About the House - Home Transparency and accountability Board of Internal Economy By-Laws and Policies Members' Allowances and Services House Administration Reports and Disclosure Conflict of Interest Code for Members Accessibility Arts and Heritage History, Art and Architecture Future of the Parliamentary Precinct Memorial Chamber Carillon In pictures Virtual Tour of the House Live Hill Cam Photo Gallery Employment Employment - Home Working for the administration Current Opportunities at the House of Commons Eligibility and Selection General Application Who We Are and What We Offer Student Opportunities Student Employment Page Program Parliamentary Internship Programme Working for a Member of Parliament Current Listed Opportunities Working for a Member of Parliament Search Search Search Search Source Full website Member Bill Topic Petition Writen Question Parliamentary Business Parliamentary Business - Home The House Sitting Calendar House Publications Bills (LEGIS info ) Written Questions Petitions Votes Search the Debates (Hansard) Status of House Business Committees List of Committees and Overview Meetings Bills in Committee (LEGIS info ) Studies, Activities and Reports Search the Transcripts Participate Resources Procedural Information Library of Parliament Legislative Summaries Research Publications Parliamentary Historical Resources (1867-1993) Parliamentary Diplomacy Parliamentary Diplomacy - Home Speakers' Activities Parliamentary Associations Visits and Events Conferences Parliamentary Officers' Study Program Members Members - Home Members and Roles Members of Parliament The Speaker Ministry (Cabinet) Parliamentary Secretaries Party Leaders and other House Officers Related Information Party Standings Seating Plan Members' Expenditures Registry of Designated Travellers A Member's Typical Week Resources Contact Members of Parliament Constituencies Library of Parliament Historical Information (PARLINFO) Participate Participate - Home The House Attend Live Debates Watch and Listen to Chamber Proceedings Create or Sign a Petition A Typical Week at the House Contact a Member of Parliament Follow a Bill (LEGIS info ) Committees Attend Meetings Watch and Listen to Committee Proceedings Current Consultations How to Submit a Brief and Appear Layout of a Typical Committee Room Contact a Committee Resources Procedural Information Library of Parliament Classroom Activities Teacher Resources Teachers Institute About the House About the House - Home Transparency and accountability Board of Internal Economy By-Laws and Policies Members' Allowances and Services House Administration Reports and Disclosure Conflict of Interest Code for Members Accessibility Arts and Heritage History, Art and Architecture Future of the Parliamentary Precinct Memorial Chamber Carillon In pictures Virtual Tour of the House Live Hill Cam Photo Gallery Employment Employment - Home Working for the administration Current Opportunities at the House of Commons Eligibility and Selection General Application Who We Are and What We Offer Student Opportunities Student Employment Page Program Parliamentary Internship Programme Working for a Member of Parliament Current Listed Opportunities Working for a Member of Parliament Search Search Search Search Source Full website Member Bill Topic Petition Writen Question Search all ProceduralInfo Overview Procedure and Practice Standing Orders Speakers' Decisions Our Procedure Glossary Selected Decisions of Speaker Peter Milliken 2001 - 2011 Selected Decisions Peter Milliken Private Members’ Business Financial Limitation Table of Contents Previous Next Private Members’ Business / Financial Limitation Establishment of first Order of Precedence: Speaker’s statement regarding royal recommendation February 25, 2009 Debates, pp. 968-9 Context On February 25, 2009, immediately prior to the first occasion on which Private Members’ Business was to be taken up in the Fortieth Parliament, the Speaker made a statement with regard to the management of Private Members’ Business. He drew particular attention to the rules requiring that a royal recommendation accompany “any bill which authorizes the spending of public funds for a new and distinct purpose or effects an appropriation of public funds”. He indicated that he would continue the practice of notifying the House of those items of Private Members’ Business that appeared to need a royal recommendation. Statement of the Chair The Speaker: Honourable Members will want to hear all about Private Members’ Business in this fascinating statement. At the beginning of the last Parliament on May 31, 2006, as well as at the beginning of the one before that on November 18, 2004, I reminded all hon. Members about the procedures governing Private Members’ Business and the responsibilities of the Chair in the management of this process. Given that the House is about to take up Private Members’ Business for the first time in this Parliament later this afternoon, I would like to make a statement regarding the management of Private Members’ Business. As Members know, certain constitutional procedural realities constrain the Speaker and Members insofar as legislation is concerned. One procedural principle that I have underscored in a number of statements over the course of the two preceding Parliaments concerns the possibility that certain private Member’s bills may require a royal recommendation. The requirement for a royal recommendation is grounded in constitutional principles found in the Constitution Act, 1867 . The language of section 54 of that Act is echoed in Standing Order 79(1), which reads: This House shall not adopt or pass any vote, resolution, address or bill for the appropriation of any part of the public revenue, or of any tax or impost, to any purpose that has not been first recommended to the House by a message from the Governor General in the session in which such vote, resolution, address or bill is proposed. Any bill which authorizes the spending of public funds for a new and distinct purpose or effects an appropriation of public funds must be accompanied by a message from the Governor General recommending the expenditure to the House. This message, known formally as the royal recommendation, can only be transmitted to the House by a Minister of the Crown. Such bills may be introduced and considered right up until third reading on the assumption that a royal recommendation could be provided by a Minister. If none is produced by the conclusion of the third reading stage, the Speaker is required to stop proceedings and rule the bill out of order. Following the establishment and replenishment of the Order of Precedence, the Chair has developed the practice of reviewing items so that the House can be alerted to bills which, at first glance, appear to impinge on the financial prerogative of the Crown. The aim of this practice is to allow Members the opportunity to intervene in a timely fashion to present their views about the need for those bills to be accompanied by a royal recommendation. Accordingly, following the establishment of the Order of Precedence on February 13, 2009, I wish to draw the attention of the House to five bills that give the Chair some concern as to the spending provisions they contemplate. These are: Bill C-201, An Act to amend the Canadian Forces Superannuation Act and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police Superannuation Act (deletion of deduction from annuity) , standing in the name of the Member for Sackville–Eastern Shore; Bill C-241, An Act to amend the Employment Insurance Act (removal of waiting period) , standing in the name of the Member for Brome–Missisquoi; Bill C-279, An Act to amend the Employment Insurance Act (amounts not included in earnings) , standing in the name of the hon. Member for Welland; Bill C-280, An Act to amend the Employment Insurance Act (qualification for and entitlement to benefits) , standing in the name of the hon. Member for Algoma–Manitoulin–Kapuskasing; and Bill C-309, An Act establishing the Economic Development Agency of Canada for the Region of Northern Ontario , standing in the name of the hon. Member for Nipissing–Timiskaming. I would encourage hon. Members who would like to make arguments regarding the need for a royal recommendation for any of these bills , or with regard to any other bills now on the Order of Precedence, to do so at an early opportunity. I thank all hon. Members for their attention to this important ruling. Editor’s Note See similar statements at the creation of the first complete Order of Precedence of the Thirty-Eighth Parliament on November 18, 2004, and of the Thirty-Ninth Parliament on May 31, 2006. For questions about parliamentary procedure, contact the Table Research Branch 613-996-3611 trbdrb@parl.gc.ca Top of page Senate Library of Parliament Parliamentary Protective Service Employment at Parliament Follow Us Important Notices Open Data Info for Media Site Map Accessibility Contact Us