Search thousands of Speaker's rulings with AI-powered precision.
September 18, 1973
Questions Related to Content of Bills / Infringing on Financial Initiative of the Crown September 18, 1973 Journals pp. 561-2 Debates p. 6690 Background On January 18, the Speaker proposed to...
The provided text is a procedural phrase, not a complete ruling, and cannot be analyzed.
September 13, 1973
"A bill, or an amendment to a bill cannot propose the expenditure of fonds without a recommendation of the Crown." Since the present bill is not accompanied by a Royal Recommendation, it cannot be...
The Speaker ruled a private member's bill out of order because it proposed spending public money without a required Royal Recommendation.
June 11, 1973
Amendments to the Content of Bills / Report Stage June 11, 1973 Debates p. 4650 Background During debate at the report stage on the motion in amendment of Mr. Woolliams (Calgary North.) relating...
A ruling on an amendment's admissibility concerning the principles of relevance and the financial initiative of the Crown.
June 11, 1973
Amendments to the Content of Bills / Report Stage June 11, 1973 Debates p. 4626 Background During debate at report stage of Bill C-133, an Act to amend the National Housing Act, Mr. Broadbent...
The Speaker ruled that a legislative matter was compliant with the financial authority granted by the Royal Recommendation.
June 11, 1973
No amendments can be moved "to the granting or enacting words of bills for granting aids or supplies to the Crown, or to the enacting words of other bills". Moreover, this specific motion in...
The Speaker ruled an amendment out of order because it improperly sought to add a preamble to a parent act not currently before the House.
April 10, 1973
It is a fundamental principle of the parliamentary system that financial initiative belongs to the Crown. A long-established practice of this House is that committee recommendations requiring...
The Speaker rules that committee reports cannot directly mandate government spending and must use specific wording to respect the financial initiative of the Crown.
March 27, 1973
Amendments to the Content of Bills / Report Stage March 27, 1973 Journals pp. 218-9 Debates pp. 2663-4 Background As the House was about to begin report stage consideration of Bill C-147, an Act...
A ruling on a point of order regarding an amendment's relevance and its potential infringement on the Crown's financial initiative.
March 26, 1973
It is not the business of the Chair to rule on points of constitutional law or to claim that the Government must resign. The issue of government resignation is not a point of order. As to the...
The Speaker denied a point of order on government resignation, affirming the Chair does not rule on constitutional matters.
February 6, 1973
Questions Related to Content of Bills / Infringing on Financial Initiative of the Crown February 6, 1973 Journals pp. 97-8 Debates p. 1018 Background At the beginning of private Members' hour,...
Analysis not possible as the provided text is a title, not a full Speaker's Ruling.
February 5, 1973
An amendment that in some way changes the objects, purposes, conditions and qualifications of the Royal Recommendation cannot be brought forward. Amendments are only in order if they fall within...
A Speaker's ruling clarifies that amendments are out of order if they exceed the scope of a Royal Recommendation or reverse the principle of the bill.